Research → Synthesis
N-P-K untested Bexar bed
Insufficient evidence·fair·$0.60 USD
A · Answer
N-P-K untested Bexar bed
Insufficient corpus evidence to produce a grounded brief on this topic. Refusal R3 · C11 · https://soiltesting.tamu.edu/
B · Evidence
No sources — the corpus could not support this goal.
Usefulness
0.58
fair- goalAlignment0.72· 25%
- nonFiller0.92· 25%
- specificity0.38· 20%
- structure0.55· 15%
- grounding0.12· 15%
Flags: insufficient_evidence, thin_sources.
Explicit insufficient-evidence result for an uncovered topic. Scored as an honest non-filler refusal, not as a grounded brief.
C · Accountability
Each step names agentId@version and the role-scoped trust move. Boards: Reputation v1.
research
agent:research.literature.v1@1.1.0
0.65→0.64
n=42
synthesize
agent:research.synthesis.v1@1.0.0
0.76→0.76
n=53
D · Economics
Quote only — no settlement. Reputation v1 is a frozen read-only input. Contract.
0.60 USDecon-v0
base 1.00
- Insufficient evidence — reduced fee-0.40
Reward weights
- agent:research.literature.v1@1.1.0research0.350rep 0.64 n=42 · modifier on
- agent:research.synthesis.v1@1.0.0synthesize0.650rep 0.76 n=53 · modifier on
Reputation v1 — frozen. readOnly true. modifier applied.
This is a first-class outcome, not a failed run. The corpus could not support a grounded brief, so synthesis refused instead of inventing one.
Advanced details
Ranking-test proof, retrieval diagnostics, step machine, claims, and raw audit. Not required to read the brief, agents, or quote.
- researchsuccess
- synthesizesuccess
Claims
No claims — the corpus had no strong topical match.
Agents
research
agent:research.literature.v1@1.1.0
synthesize
agent:research.synthesis.v1@1.0.0
Retrieval path
Diagnostics
First drop: 2 · not in candidates · corpus tenant:horticulturist
- 1Corpus
- 2Candidates
- 3Selected
- 4Synthesis
Provenance corpus membership · 5/5 found
- doc:audit-event-modelfound
- doc:agent-version-provenancefound
- doc:source-lineagefound
- doc:result-claim-provenancefound
- doc:platform-provenance-capabilitiesfound
Query
N-P-K untested Bexar bed
Top candidates · 1
- doc:tenant:horticulturist:C113
untested · strong
Low-evidence guard triggered — no strong topical match.
- CHAIN_SUBMITTED23:11:00Z
Research → synthesis: N-P-K untested Bexar bed
- WORKFLOW_SUBMITTED23:11:00Z
Research → synthesis: N-P-K untested Bexar bed
- CHAIN_STEP_STARTED23:11:00Z
Step research
- CHAIN_STEP_DONEagent:research.literature.v1@1.1.023:11:00Z
Step research success via agent:research.literature.v1@1.1.0
- RETRIEVAL_DEBUGGEDagent:research.literature.v1@1.1.023:11:00Z
Retrieval low-evidence guard · 0 selected
- CHAIN_STEP_STARTED23:11:00Z
Step synthesize
- CHAIN_STEP_DONEagent:research.synthesis.v1@1.0.023:11:00Z
Step synthesize success via agent:research.synthesis.v1@1.0.0
- CHAIN_DONE23:11:00Z
Chain success
- WORKFLOW_DONEfinalagent:research.synthesis.v1@1.0.023:11:00Z
Research → synthesis success
- USEFULNESS_SCOREDagent:research.synthesis.v1@1.0.023:11:00Z
Usefulness fair (0.58)
- TRUST_UPDATEDagent:research.literature.v1@1.1.023:11:00Z
Trust research agent:research.literature.v1@1.1.0 0.65 → 0.64
- TRUST_UPDATEDagent:research.synthesis.v1@1.0.023:11:00Z
Trust synthesize agent:research.synthesis.v1@1.0.0 0.76 → 0.76
- economic_quotedagent:research.synthesis.v1@1.0.023:11:00Z
Economic 0.60 USD
Canonical result
kind research.synthesis — brief, sources, evidenceStatus, trust, quote.
{
"result": {
"kind": "research.synthesis",
"brief": "Insufficient corpus evidence to produce a grounded brief on this topic. Refusal R3 · C11 · https://soiltesting.tamu.edu/",
"query": "N-P-K untested Bexar bed",
"summary": "Insufficient corpus evidence for this query.",
"sources": [],
"upstreamStep": "research",
"privacy": "restricted",
"evidenceStatus": "insufficient",
"reason": "no_strong_topical_match",
"corpusScope": "tenant:horticulturist"
},
"usefulness": {
"usefulnessScore": 0.58,
"usefulnessBand": "fair",
"dimensions": {
"goalAlignment": 0.72,
"nonFiller": 0.92,
"specificity": 0.38,
"structure": 0.55,
"grounding": 0.12
},
"flags": [
"insufficient_evidence",
"thin_sources"
],
"rationale": "Explicit insufficient-evidence result for an uncovered topic. Scored as an honest non-filler refusal, not as a grounded brief.",
"scorerVersion": "1.0.0"
},
"trust": {
"updates": [
{
"agentId": "agent:research.literature.v1",
"agentVersion": "1.1.0",
"role": "research",
"trustStatus": "updated",
"outcomeSignals": {
"reliability": 1,
"grounding": 0.22,
"usefulness": null
},
"trustBefore": 0.645,
"trustAfter": 0.635,
"sampleSizeAfter": 42
},
{
"agentId": "agent:research.synthesis.v1",
"agentVersion": "1.0.0",
"role": "synthesize",
"trustStatus": "updated",
"outcomeSignals": {
"reliability": 1,
"grounding": null,
"usefulness": 0.58
},
"trustBefore": 0.762,
"trustAfter": 0.759,
"sampleSizeAfter": 53
}
]
},
"ranking": null,
"economic": {
"quote": {
"total": 0.6,
"baseFee": 1,
"currency": "USD",
"adjustments": [
{
"code": "insufficient_evidence",
"label": "Insufficient evidence — reduced fee",
"amount": -0.4
}
],
"pricingVersion": "econ-v0"
},
"slice": {
"label": "Economic v0 Slice A — frozen",
"frozen": true,
"version": "0.0.0",
"pricingVersion": "econ-v0"
},
"rewards": [
{
"role": "research",
"weight": 0.35,
"agentId": "agent:research.literature.v1",
"agentVersion": "1.1.0",
"modifierApplied": true,
"reputationScore": 0.635,
"reputationSampleSize": 42
},
{
"role": "synthesize",
"weight": 0.65,
"agentId": "agent:research.synthesis.v1",
"agentVersion": "1.0.0",
"modifierApplied": true,
"reputationScore": 0.759,
"reputationSampleSize": 53
}
],
"reputationInputs": {
"label": "Reputation v1 — frozen",
"applied": true,
"version": "Reputation v1",
"readOnly": true
}
},
"retrievalDebug": {
"query": "N-P-K untested Bexar bed",
"corpusHits": [
"doc:tenant:horticulturist:C11"
],
"topCandidates": [
{
"id": "doc:tenant:horticulturist:C11",
"score": 3,
"matchedTerms": [
"untested"
],
"tags": [
"statewide"
],
"strong": true
}
],
"selectedSources": [],
"fallbackUsed": false,
"guardTriggered": true,
"corpusScope": "tenant:horticulturist"
},
"corpusMembership": [
{
"id": "doc:audit-event-model",
"found": true
},
{
"id": "doc:agent-version-provenance",
"found": true
},
{
"id": "doc:source-lineage",
"found": true
},
{
"id": "doc:result-claim-provenance",
"found": true
},
{
"id": "doc:platform-provenance-capabilities",
"found": true
}
],
"retrievalBreakpoint": "not_in_candidates"
}