Research → Synthesis
Why an SA tomato date is not automatic Austin
Grounded brief·strong·$1.15 USD
A · Answer
Why an SA tomato date is not automatic Austin
San Antonio and Austin are not the same climate.
Austin sits on the Veg Guide III–IV border (often toward III).
San Antonio nearer IV.
Neither city is III-only.
Climate-map claim, not city code.
B · Evidence
Sources
Usefulness
0.83
strong- goalAlignment0.75· 25%
- nonFiller1.00· 25%
- specificity0.75· 20%
- structure0.74· 15%
- grounding0.86· 15%
No flags.
Band strong. Strongest dimensions hold; weakest: structure 0.74, goalAlignment 0.75.
C · Accountability
Each step names agentId@version and the role-scoped trust move. Boards: Reputation v1.
research
agent:research.literature.v1@1.1.0
0.65→0.66
n=44
synthesize
agent:research.synthesis.v1@1.0.0
0.76→0.77
n=55
D · Economics
Quote only — no settlement. Reputation v1 is a frozen read-only input. Contract.
1.15 USDecon-v0
base 1.00
- Strong usefulness+0.15
Reward weights
- agent:research.literature.v1@1.1.0research0.448rep 0.66 n=44 · modifier on
- agent:research.synthesis.v1@1.0.0synthesize0.552rep 0.77 n=55 · modifier on
Reputation v1 — frozen. readOnly true. modifier applied.
Advanced details
Ranking-test proof, retrieval diagnostics, step machine, claims, and raw audit. Not required to read the brief, agents, or quote.
- researchsuccess
- synthesizesuccess
Claims
San Antonio and Austin are not the same climate. Austin sits on the Veg Guide III–IV border (often toward III). San Antonio nearer IV. Neither city is III-only. Climate-map claim, not city code.
0.92 · doc:tenant:horticulturist:C15
AgriLife Fall / Home Vegetable Gardening Guide uses regions I–V. Last-optimum tomato/pepper/eggplant June 25 in Region I vs September 1 in Region V. No statewide planting calendar.
0.70 · doc:tenant:horticulturist:C14
Agents
research
agent:research.literature.v1@1.1.0
synthesize
agent:research.synthesis.v1@1.0.0
Retrieval path
Diagnostics
First drop: 2 · not in candidates · corpus tenant:horticulturist
- 1Corpus
- 2Candidates
- 3Selected
- 4Synthesis
Provenance corpus membership · 5/5 found
- doc:audit-event-modelfound
- doc:agent-version-provenancefound
- doc:source-lineagefound
- doc:result-claim-provenancefound
- doc:platform-provenance-capabilitiesfound
Query
Why an SA tomato date is not automatic Austin
Top candidates · 17
- doc:tenant:horticulturist:C1522
not · austin · strong · selected · in brief
- doc:tenant:horticulturist:C1014
not · austin · strong
- doc:tenant:horticulturist:C1614
not · austin · strong
- doc:tenant:horticulturist:C1714
not · austin · strong
- doc:tenant:horticulturist:C714
not · austin · strong
- doc:tenant:horticulturist:C814
tomato · not · strong
- doc:tenant:horticulturist:C69
date · not · austin · strong
- doc:tenant:horticulturist:C16
date · not · strong
- doc:tenant:horticulturist:C36
not · austin · strong
- doc:tenant:horticulturist:C96
not · austin · strong
- doc:tenant:horticulturist:C113
not · strong
- doc:tenant:horticulturist:C123
not · strong
- doc:tenant:horticulturist:C133
not · strong
- doc:tenant:horticulturist:C143
tomato · strong · selected · in brief
- doc:tenant:horticulturist:C183
not · strong
- doc:tenant:horticulturist:C43
not · strong
- doc:tenant:horticulturist:C53
not · strong
Selected
doc:tenant:horticulturist:C15 · doc:tenant:horticulturist:C14
- CHAIN_SUBMITTED23:12:19Z
Research → synthesis: Why an SA tomato date is not automatic Austin
- WORKFLOW_SUBMITTED23:12:19Z
Research → synthesis: Why an SA tomato date is not automatic Austin
- CHAIN_STEP_STARTED23:12:19Z
Step research
- CHAIN_STEP_DONEagent:research.literature.v1@1.1.023:12:20Z
Step research success via agent:research.literature.v1@1.1.0
- RETRIEVAL_DEBUGGEDagent:research.literature.v1@1.1.023:12:20Z
Retrieval hits · 2 selected
- CHAIN_STEP_STARTED23:12:20Z
Step synthesize
- CHAIN_STEP_DONEagent:research.synthesis.v1@1.0.023:12:20Z
Step synthesize success via agent:research.synthesis.v1@1.0.0
- CHAIN_DONE23:12:20Z
Chain success
- WORKFLOW_DONEfinalagent:research.synthesis.v1@1.0.023:12:20Z
Research → synthesis success
- USEFULNESS_SCOREDagent:research.synthesis.v1@1.0.023:12:20Z
Usefulness strong (0.83)
- TRUST_UPDATEDagent:research.literature.v1@1.1.023:12:20Z
Trust research agent:research.literature.v1@1.1.0 0.65 → 0.66
- TRUST_UPDATEDagent:research.synthesis.v1@1.0.023:12:20Z
Trust synthesize agent:research.synthesis.v1@1.0.0 0.76 → 0.77
- economic_quotedagent:research.synthesis.v1@1.0.023:12:20Z
Economic 1.15 USD
Canonical result
kind research.synthesis — brief, sources, evidenceStatus, trust, quote.
{
"result": {
"kind": "research.synthesis",
"brief": "San Antonio and Austin are not the same climate. Austin sits on the Veg Guide III–IV border (often toward III). San Antonio nearer IV. Neither city is III-only. Climate-map claim, not city code. Sources: doc:tenant:horticulturist:C15 — San Antonio and Austin are not the same climate.; doc:tenant:horticulturist:C14 — AgriLife Fall / Home Vegetable Gardening Guide uses regions I–V..",
"query": "Why an SA tomato date is not automatic Austin",
"summary": "Synthesized 1 focused claim from 2 sources.",
"sources": [
"doc:tenant:horticulturist:C15",
"doc:tenant:horticulturist:C14"
],
"upstreamStep": "research",
"privacy": "restricted",
"evidenceStatus": "sufficient",
"reason": "strong_topical_match",
"corpusScope": "tenant:horticulturist"
},
"usefulness": {
"flags": [],
"rationale": "Band strong. Strongest dimensions hold; weakest: structure 0.74, goalAlignment 0.75.",
"dimensions": {
"grounding": 0.86,
"nonFiller": 1,
"structure": 0.74,
"specificity": 0.75,
"goalAlignment": 0.75
},
"scorerVersion": "1.0.0",
"usefulnessBand": "strong",
"usefulnessScore": 0.83
},
"trust": {
"updates": [
{
"agentId": "agent:research.literature.v1",
"agentVersion": "1.1.0",
"role": "research",
"trustStatus": "updated",
"outcomeSignals": {
"reliability": 1,
"grounding": 0.88,
"usefulness": null
},
"trustBefore": 0.647,
"trustAfter": 0.657,
"sampleSizeAfter": 44
},
{
"agentId": "agent:research.synthesis.v1",
"agentVersion": "1.0.0",
"role": "synthesize",
"trustStatus": "updated",
"outcomeSignals": {
"reliability": 1,
"grounding": null,
"usefulness": 0.83
},
"trustBefore": 0.764,
"trustAfter": 0.767,
"sampleSizeAfter": 55
}
]
},
"ranking": null,
"economic": {
"quote": {
"total": 1.15,
"baseFee": 1,
"currency": "USD",
"adjustments": [
{
"code": "usefulness_strong",
"label": "Strong usefulness",
"amount": 0.15
}
],
"pricingVersion": "econ-v0"
},
"slice": {
"label": "Economic v0 Slice A — frozen",
"frozen": true,
"version": "0.0.0",
"pricingVersion": "econ-v0"
},
"rewards": [
{
"role": "research",
"weight": 0.448,
"agentId": "agent:research.literature.v1",
"agentVersion": "1.1.0",
"modifierApplied": true,
"reputationScore": 0.657,
"reputationSampleSize": 44
},
{
"role": "synthesize",
"weight": 0.552,
"agentId": "agent:research.synthesis.v1",
"agentVersion": "1.0.0",
"modifierApplied": true,
"reputationScore": 0.767,
"reputationSampleSize": 55
}
],
"reputationInputs": {
"label": "Reputation v1 — frozen",
"applied": true,
"version": "Reputation v1",
"readOnly": true
}
},
"retrievalDebug": {
"query": "Why an SA tomato date is not automatic Austin",
"corpusHits": [
"doc:tenant:horticulturist:C15",
"doc:tenant:horticulturist:C10",
"doc:tenant:horticulturist:C16",
"doc:tenant:horticulturist:C17",
"doc:tenant:horticulturist:C7",
"doc:tenant:horticulturist:C8",
"doc:tenant:horticulturist:C6",
"doc:tenant:horticulturist:C1",
"doc:tenant:horticulturist:C3",
"doc:tenant:horticulturist:C9",
"doc:tenant:horticulturist:C11",
"doc:tenant:horticulturist:C12",
"doc:tenant:horticulturist:C13",
"doc:tenant:horticulturist:C14",
"doc:tenant:horticulturist:C18",
"doc:tenant:horticulturist:C4",
"doc:tenant:horticulturist:C5"
],
"corpusScope": "tenant:horticulturist",
"fallbackUsed": false,
"topCandidates": [
{
"id": "doc:tenant:horticulturist:C15",
"tags": [
"bexar",
"travis"
],
"score": 22,
"strong": true,
"matchedTerms": [
"not",
"austin"
]
},
{
"id": "doc:tenant:horticulturist:C10",
"tags": [
"statewide"
],
"score": 14,
"strong": true,
"matchedTerms": [
"not",
"austin"
]
},
{
"id": "doc:tenant:horticulturist:C16",
"tags": [
"travis"
],
"score": 14,
"strong": true,
"matchedTerms": [
"not",
"austin"
]
},
{
"id": "doc:tenant:horticulturist:C17",
"tags": [
"bexar",
"travis"
],
"score": 14,
"strong": true,
"matchedTerms": [
"not",
"austin"
]
},
{
"id": "doc:tenant:horticulturist:C7",
"tags": [
"bexar"
],
"score": 14,
"strong": true,
"matchedTerms": [
"not",
"austin"
]
},
{
"id": "doc:tenant:horticulturist:C8",
"tags": [
"bexar",
"travis"
],
"score": 14,
"strong": true,
"matchedTerms": [
"tomato",
"not"
]
},
{
"id": "doc:tenant:horticulturist:C6",
"tags": [
"statewide"
],
"score": 9,
"strong": true,
"matchedTerms": [
"date",
"not",
"austin"
]
},
{
"id": "doc:tenant:horticulturist:C1",
"tags": [
"lrgv"
],
"score": 6,
"strong": true,
"matchedTerms": [
"date",
"not"
]
},
{
"id": "doc:tenant:horticulturist:C3",
"tags": [
"bexar"
],
"score": 6,
"strong": true,
"matchedTerms": [
"not",
"austin"
]
},
{
"id": "doc:tenant:horticulturist:C9",
"tags": [
"statewide"
],
"score": 6,
"strong": true,
"matchedTerms": [
"not",
"austin"
]
},
{
"id": "doc:tenant:horticulturist:C11",
"tags": [
"statewide"
],
"score": 3,
"strong": true,
"matchedTerms": [
"not"
]
},
{
"id": "doc:tenant:horticulturist:C12",
"tags": [
"lrgv"
],
"score": 3,
"strong": true,
"matchedTerms": [
"not"
]
},
{
"id": "doc:tenant:horticulturist:C13",
"tags": [
"statewide"
],
"score": 3,
"strong": true,
"matchedTerms": [
"not"
]
},
{
"id": "doc:tenant:horticulturist:C14",
"tags": [
"statewide"
],
"score": 3,
"strong": true,
"matchedTerms": [
"tomato"
]
},
{
"id": "doc:tenant:horticulturist:C18",
"tags": [
"bexar",
"travis"
],
"score": 3,
"strong": true,
"matchedTerms": [
"not"
]
},
{
"id": "doc:tenant:horticulturist:C4",
"tags": [
"lrgv"
],
"score": 3,
"strong": true,
"matchedTerms": [
"not"
]
},
{
"id": "doc:tenant:horticulturist:C5",
"tags": [
"lrgv"
],
"score": 3,
"strong": true,
"matchedTerms": [
"not"
]
}
],
"guardTriggered": false,
"selectedSources": [
"doc:tenant:horticulturist:C15",
"doc:tenant:horticulturist:C14"
]
},
"corpusMembership": [
{
"id": "doc:audit-event-model",
"found": true
},
{
"id": "doc:agent-version-provenance",
"found": true
},
{
"id": "doc:source-lineage",
"found": true
},
{
"id": "doc:result-claim-provenance",
"found": true
},
{
"id": "doc:platform-provenance-capabilities",
"found": true
}
],
"retrievalBreakpoint": "not_in_candidates"
}